ABUJA, Nigeria – In a nation where family is revered as the backbone of identity and belonging, a hidden crisis is quietly corroding trust within Nigerian households. Beneath the surface of smiling family portraits and proud fathers lies a shocking statistic: one in every four men tested through Smart DNA Nigeria are not the biological fathers of the children they have raised.
The surge in paternity testing—rising by 13.1% in the past year—is not just a by-product of the “Japa” emigration trend. It exposes deeper fractures: eroded trust in relationships, marital infidelity, and legal systems ill-equipped to deal with the fallout.
As personal stories emerge and data mounts, Nigeria is being forced to confront uncomfortable truths. Behind every statistic is a devastated father, a betrayed spouse, or a child caught in emotional crossfire. Experts warn of the psychological toll, lawyers highlight gaping legal voids, and advocates demand reform. In this special report, Juliet Jacob, explores the raw human experiences, the cultural dimensions, and the urgent call for change.
The Human Face of Betrayal: Fathers in Shattered Worlds
For many Nigerian men, the discovery of paternity fraud begins in the most ordinary circumstances. For an Abuja businessman, the revelation came when he sought a DNA test to support his son’s application for overseas education.
“He was in his final year of law school, and I had poured in everything—my savings, my dreams, my pride. Then the test result said I was not his father. It felt like my entire life was a lie,” he told Africa Health Report through tears.
Also, firstborn children, particularly sons, have been shown to carry the highest burden of paternity fraud, with an alarming 64% non-paternity rate among tested cases. One of the most heartbreaking examples involved a man married for 25 years who, after stumbling on online videos about DNA testing, decided to secretly test all six of his children.
A family counsellor who supported the couple recounted to Africa Health Report (AHR) said “He had always believed his wife was the perfect partner, the love of his life. But the DNA results were devastating—none of the six children were biologically his. Even children born before their marriage were tested, and only one from a previous relationship turned out to be his. The impact was catastrophic: the marriage collapsed, he sank into deep depression, and the entire family structure crumbled.”
Their stories are far from unique. Data suggests Nigeria has one of the highest global rates of paternity fraud—second only to Jamaica. Roughly 30% of paternity tests in Nigeria reveal non-biological relationships, compared to just 2.8% in Canada, 1.6% in the UK, and 1.4% in France.
The consequences are devastating collapsed marriages, financial disputes, and emotional trauma. In one case, a Lagos father discovered—after 25 years of marriage—that none of his six children shared his DNA. He slipped into deep depression, and the family disintegrated.
Numbers That Tell a Painful Story
According to Smart DNA Nigeria’s recent report, 25% of fathers tested were not biologically related to their children, and men initiated almost 90% of tests, while women accounted for just 11.8%.
It further shows that the firstborn children, particularly sons, are most likely to be affected, with a shocking 64% non-paternity rate, Yoruba men make up more than half of those seeking tests, followed by Igbo men (33%), with Hausa men at just 1.2%—a reflection of differing cultural norms and urbanisation.
Operations manager, Smart DNA Nigeria, Elizabeth Digia, summarised the crisis:
“These figures raise urgent questions about trust and family structures. Nigeria has no dedicated law on paternity fraud, unlike South Africa, leaving men with no recourse despite years of financial responsibility. Normalising DNA testing as part of family planning and premarital counselling could prevent lifelong betrayals.”
The Experts Weigh In: Trauma, Law, and Culture
“Mental Health: Wounds Beyond Finances”
In an interview with AHR, a psychiatrist and mental health advocate, Dr Maymunah Kadiri warns of severe psychological fallout saying, “Discovering paternity fraud triggers depression, anxiety, rage, and sometimes suicidal thoughts. Many men report feelings of emasculation, which increase risks of hypertension, cardiac issues, and substance abuse. We need support systems, counselling, and destigmatisation.”
Law: An Empty Space in Nigeria’s Courts
A legal practitioner, Barrister Femi Akinyemi said “Nigeria lacks specific legislation on paternity fraud. Men who have unknowingly invested financially in non-biological children have little or no legal remedy. Options like DNA testing at birth or during custody cases should be considered, but safeguards for privacy and children’s welfare are essential.”
Culture: Stigma and Silence
Sociologist, Prof. Abayomi links the issue to gender dynamics saying, “In patriarchal societies like Nigeria, men’s identities are strongly tied to fatherhood. Infidelity carries shame, but so does infertility. The silence around these issues fuels suspicion and resentment. Addressing it requires both policy reform and cultural education.”
The Japa Factor: When Migration Tests Break Families
Paternity fraud increasingly comes to light during visa applications in the “Japa” migration wave. Many embassies, including the United States, mandate DNA testing in certain family reunification categories.
A migration officer from the International Organisation for Migration (IOM) Nigeria explained:
“Families are often blindsided by test results during visa applications. Some find out at the embassy that their family structure is not what they believed. The emotional and logistical fallout is huge.”
An immigration lawyer recalled a case where a family relocating to the U.S. was torn apart after DNA testing proved the father was not biological. The relocation was denied, leaving behind grief and broken trust.
Social Ripples: Beyond the Family Unit
The consequences extend beyond individuals to society at large. Economically, men often shoulder years of financial responsibility for children not biologically theirs. Emotionally, families fracture, children are stigmatised, and communities lose cohesion.
From a health perspective, the rising tide of depression, anxiety, and stress-related illness linked to paternity fraud adds strain to Nigeria’s fragile mental health infrastructure.
Policy debates are intensifying: Should DNA testing be mandatory at birth? Would such laws protect families, or invade privacy?
Women’s rights advocates, such as Mrs. Chidinma of the Women Advocates Research and Documentation Centre (WARDC), urge caution: “Mandatory testing may solve some issues but creates new ethical problems. What about the rights of mothers? What about children’s privacy? Balanced reform is what we need—policies that protect men, women, and children alike.”
Towards Reform: What Needs to Change?
Experts and advocates are unanimous: Nigeria must act. The way forward includes Legal Reform: Introducing laws that address paternity fraud, ensuring financial responsibility is fairly shared, and considering DNA testing in custody disputes.
Counselling & Support: Expanding psychological support through bodies like the Nigerian Psychological Association.
Public Awareness: Destigmatising DNA testing and promoting open discussions around fidelity, family planning, and reproductive health.
Balanced Rights: Protecting children from stigma while giving men fair recourse in fraud cases.
As Nigeria wrestles with the realities of paternity fraud, one father’s reflection captures the deep wounds left behind, “I’ve lost more than money—I’ve lost faith in love. But for my children’s sake, we must find a way forward,” said Mr. Adebayo, still reeling from his discovery.
His pain mirrors that of countless men navigating betrayal, countless women defending their choices, and countless children caught in between. The truth of DNA has ripped through silence, forcing a national reckoning.
Whether Nigeria responds with denial, reform, or compassion will determine not just the future of families, but the integrity of the nation’s most sacred institution—the bond between parent and child.
oxfdnpelzvjpuvhqggqptgplesqvti